The fickle finger of basketball fans (NCAA Tournament)
Kansas and coach Bill Self survived Davidson (barely) last night 59-57, turning the stagecoach that brought Davidson to the Elite Eight back into a pumpkin and punching Bill Self’s first ever Final Four dance card.
All the teams in this year’s Final Four are No. 1 seeds, and some fans have a smug sense of satisfaction about it. As if we’re seeing things like they are supposed to be. Like the tournament finally “worked”. How fickle we are. Everybody loves the Cinderella team—as long as they don’t overstay their welcome.
In the early rounds of March, people love predicting upsets. They love seeing the big guy go down early, and they love predicting it. Most people I talked to after the first round pretty much said the same thing:
“Dude . . . Sienna? Are you kidding me? SIENNA?!”
The shock factor is what keeps the tournament so irresistible, but apparently our love affair with the underdog is matter of convenience rather than practicality. Seems to be the case with Davidson, anyway.
You’d be crazy not to hand it to Stephen Curry and the Davidson team. Every single tournament has its upstarts, and no matter how many dictionaries you use, you won’t find a better definition than the Wildcats.
The country loved them, too. Stephen Curry has been called the “Sophomore Sensation”, and Davidson was quickly dubbed “America’s Sweethearts”. But this morning, people have dropped Davidson with a thud sounding eerily similar to Jason Richards’ last-ditch three-point attempt to steal a win from Kansas.
Now, after all of Davidson’s talented, gritty, and honest play, people are describing them as “plucky”. Isn’t that cute?
Hindsight is 20/20, I suppose, and now that every single basketball powerhouse that started this tournament is still in it, some people think it would have been weird or even awkward if Davidson had beaten Kansas for a spot in the Final Four.
As if Davidson really wouldn’t have belonged there after all. As if Davidson’s losing were for the best.
Would North Carolina have crushed Davidson? Probably, but they managed to put the brakes on Kansas and that’s saying something.
I’m just as excited as the next guy over all four No. 1 seeds still remaining. It’s never happened before and we’re going to see some heavyweight basketball, but I don’t think it’s fair for anyone to be so dismissive of Davidson.
I don’t think it’s fair for any of us to say they don’t belong in the Final Four. They didn’t technically belong in the Elite Eight, either. Those kids can play, and they proved it.
The tournament is designed with the sole purpose of protecting No. 1 seeds as long as possible. The bracket favors them by design. So what’s more impressive here, Stephen Curry, or finally getting the Final Four we’re “supposed” to have?
If this is the way things are supposed to be every year, why bother playing a tournament?
–Joey Alfino, RED Editorial Staff.


It was a typical museum scene: a bunch of male teens on a field trip were laughing and shoving each other around, barely paying attention to the exhibits. But as the boisterous group entered the final display in Memphis’